Obama Administration Serious About Jobs, Creators
Wednesday, December 16th, 2009 by Patrick RossThree cheers to the Obama Administration for hosting Tuesday at the White House a key jobs summit, one involving the jobs of creators and their collaborators in creation. The Associated Press quoted the host of the event, Vice president Joseph Biden, as saying of copyright piracy:
“This is flat unadulterated theft, and it should be dealt with,” Biden said. “We are committed to making some real inroads — to stop the talking and start the acting.”
Many high-level Obama Administration officials were present and committed to increased protection of the rights of copyright owners, including some who have spoken forcefully in the past on the importance of copyright protection, such as Commerce Secretary Gary Locke and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Director David Kappos. Attorney General Eric Holder and FBI Director Robert Mueller were there, part of a commitment for more robust action at the Department of Justice against infringement, to be funded in part by new monies and programs that resulted from last year’s passage of the PRO-IP Act.
The PRO-IP Act also led to the creation of an Intellectual Property Enforcement Coordinator at the White House. Victoria Espinel just received Senate clearance for that post, and was on hand Tuesday as well.
Biden and other Obama Administration officials noted the millions of jobs at stake, from individual creators to workers in copyright industries from make-up artists to engineers, as well as the billions of dollars lost to the U.S. economy by piracy. As the AP put it: “Calling it a top priority, the Obama administration said it will draw on law enforcement, trade agreements and other pressure to force compliance with copyright laws.”
This is a welcome move by the Administration. Many of its Cabinet members, including USTR Ron Kirk, have spoken forcefully about the need to enforce copyright owners’ rights, but a White House summit certainly helps. There are many problems in our economy that cannot easily be solved by government action.
But there are many steps the U.S. government can take, small steps that yield large rewards.
During the PRO-IP debate, respected economists noted that cutting losses due to counterfeiting by even five to ten percent would create at least 174,000 new U.S. jobs per year after three years. During that time, overall U.S. economic output would increase by at least $27 billion due to domestic production reclaiming the market from pirated goods. For every tax dollar spent on increased intellectual property enforcement as a result of the steps called for in PRO-IP, at least three new dollars in federal taxes would be collected, and federal tax revenue would increase $1.4 billion or more over 3 years.
One of the authors of that study was Dr. Laura Tyson, an MIT-trained economist who was the chief economic advisor for President Bill Clinton and teaches at the University of California, Berkeley.
Several unions were represented at the White House event, one of many types of organizations that represents individual creators in the copyright community. Those unions put out a statement thanking Vice President Biden and the Administration for the summit and for their commitment to increased enforcement of creators’ rights. Noting piracy was eroding the funds the unions use to provide health care and pensions to members, they added:
But if intellectual property can be protected from the insidious threat posed by digital theft and counterfeiting, the Internet can become the vehicle for innovation, creation, ingenuity and job growth, instead of the undoing of a vital domestic industry. This is wholly dependent upon the creation and implementation of regulations, laws and programs to prevent, deter and enforce against the crime of digital theft.
As we saw during the PRO-IP debate, we have many laws in this country, and around the world, meant to protect creators’ rights, but enforcement is sorely lacking. All of us as consumers of copyrighted works benefit when there is a market to create those works, and thus benefit from increased enforcement of those rights and laws.
Not everyone was happy with yesterday’s summit. I blogged yesterday about how some on the extreme of this debate won’t accept even the notion that there is clear, black-and-white piracy that benefits no one but the thieves, to borrow Vice President Biden’s turn of phrase; this piracy harms creators and their professional partners and makes it more difficult for future creative works to be financed and produced.
We saw another example of this striking lack of acknowledgment of reality in a statement by a group dedicated to reducing copyright owners’ rights. The statement was the latest attack on the Obama administration by a group that championed then-Senator Barack Obama during the 2008 campaign; having been in Washington twenty years, I’m still amazed when folks turn on their own in a public and aggressive manner.
Back in April, the Copyright Alliance joined with forty other unions, artists’ alliances, think tanks, corporations and trade associations in defending President Obama and his Administration from a similar, narrow-minded attack from some of his “friends.”
This latest attack will be unlikely to be taken with much seriousness by the Administration. For one, it suggests that Vice President Biden knows little about intellectual property: “If Vice President Biden is truly interested in learning more about intellectual property, we hope he will continue his consultations with a group of people who share a wider range of views than those with whom he will meet today.”
Yup, at a summit focused on jobs and economic activity, the Vice President met with those creating jobs and employed in an industry producing great economic activity. How reckless of him.
The Vice President, while a Senator, was one of the foremost experts on intellectual property and its contributions to our economy. He shared some of his expertise this spring in speaking at an event in D.C., but anyone who observed him as the former Chairman of the Senate Judiciary and Foreign Relations Committees saw that knowledge in action. Oh, and did I mention that he was a co-founder and co-chairman of the Congressional International Anti-Piracy Caucus?
Yes, the best way to influence the Vice President of the United States is to tell him he has a lot to learn about an area of his expertise. Smooth.
We like to focus on the positive at the Copyright Alliance, and once again — just as when we took individual creators recently to a warm meeting at the White House — we have many positives to focus on with the Obama Administration.
On behalf of all artists and creators and copyright owners, thank you.
Here’s the media advisory from the White House, reprinted below:
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
December 14, 2009
**MEDIA ADVISORY**
Vice President Biden to Host Roundtable Discussion on Enforcing Laws Against Piracy of Intellectual Property
WASHINGTON, D.C .– Tomorrow, Tuesday, December 15, at 3:15 PM EST, the Vice President will hold a roundtable discussion on this Administration’s commitment to enforcing laws against the piracy of intellectual property. The Vice President will be joined by Attorney General Eric Holder, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke, FBI Director Robert Mueller, USSS Director Mark Sullivan, as well as CEOs from major media conglomerates, union representatives, legal experts and other government officials. This White House meeting is the first of its kind, and will bring together all of the stakeholders to discuss ways to combat piracy in this rapidly changing technological age.
The opening remarks by the Vice President, Attorney General Holder, Secretary Napolitano and Secretary Locke will be POOLED for TV cameras, and OPEN to print, online, radio and still photographers. An RSVP is required to participate.
WHAT: Vice President Biden to hold roundtable discussion on this Administration’s commitment to enforcing laws against the piracy of intellectual property.
WHO: Vice President Joe Biden
Attorney General Eric Holder
Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano
Secretary of Commerce Gary Locke
FBI Director Robert Mueller
USSS Director Mark Sullivan
CEOs from major media conglomerates, union representatives, legal experts and other government officials
*Full List of Meeting Attendees is included below
WHEN: Tuesday, December 15, 2009
3:15 PM EST
Gather time: 2:30 PM EST on Jackson Place, outside the White House Conference Center
WHERE: White House Conference Center
726 Jackson Place (adjacent to Lafayette Square Park)
RSVP: Press who wish to cover this event should RSVP to press@ovp.eop.gov
at 11:00 AM EST and include their Date of Birth and Social Security Number.
###
Full List of Meeting Attendees:
The Honorable Joe Biden
Vice President of the United States
The Honorable Eric Holder
United States Attorney General
The Honorable Gary Locke
United States Secretary of Commerce
The Honorable Janet Napolitano
United States Secretary of Homeland Security
The Honorable Robert S. Mueller
Director, Federal Bureau of Investigation
The Honorable John T. Morton
Assistant Secretary, United States Immigration & Customs Enforcement
Department of Homeland Security
The Honorable David Kappos
Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and
Director, United States Patent & Trademark Office
The Honorable Douglas A. Smith
Assistant Secretary, Office of the Private Sector
Department of Homeland Security
Valerie Jarrett
Senior Advisor and Director, Office of Intergovernmental Affairs and Public Engagement
The White House
Mark J. Sullivan
Director, United States Secret Service
Michael Lynton
Chairman & CEO, Sony Pictures Entertainment
Barry Meyer
Chairman & CEO, Warner Bros. Entertainment
Carol Melton
Executive Vice President, Time Warner Inc.
Philippe Dauman
Chairman & CEO, Viacom
DeDe Lea
Executive Vice President, Viacom
Jeffrey Zucker
CEO, NBC Universal
Rick Cotton
General Counsel, NBC Universal
Alec French
Vice President, NCB Universal
Edgar Bronfman
CEO, Warner Music Group
Linda Bloss-Baum
Vice President, Warner Music Group
Brian Murray
President & CEO, Harper Collins
Zachary Horowitz
President & COO, Universal Music Group
Matthew Gerson
Executive Vice President, Universal Music Group
Michael Regan
Executive Vice President, News Corporation
Richard Bates
Senior Vice President, The Walt Disney Company
Toni Bush
Partner, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP
Daniel Glickman
Chairman & CEO, Motion Picture Association of America
Mitch Bainwol
Chairman & CEO, Recording Industry Association of America
Matthew Loeb
International President, The International Alliance of Theatrical Stage
Employees, Moving Picture Technicians, Artists and Allied Crafts of
the United States
Kim Roberts Hedgpeth
National Executive Director, American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
Taylor Hackford
President, Directors Guild of America
Jay Roth
National Executive Director, Directors Guild of America
David Israelite
President & CEO, National Music Publishers’ Association
David White
National Executive Director & Chief Negotiator, Screen Actors Guild
Alan Hoffman
Deputy Chief of Staff, Office of the Vice President
Victoria Espinel
Intellectual Property Enforcement Coordinator, Office of Management &
Budget
Terrell McSweeny
Domestic Policy Advisor, Office of the Vice President
Andrew Kline
Senior Advisor for Crime Policy, Office of the Vice President
Susan Davies
Associate Counsel to the President
James Garland
Counselor to the Attorney General and Deputy Chief of Staff, Department of Justice
###
